March 3, 2007

Coulter Said What? (Bumped)

Ann Coulter is speaking at the moment, and drawing a huge crowd -- with longer lines than those for the Rudy Giuliani. She's definitely one of the stars here at CPAC, and I listened to the audio stream for a bit while she opened her speech. I had to take a phone call, though, and I missed a critical, and infuriating, throw-away line. Michelle Malkin reports (from two chairs down):

"I'd say something about John Edwards, but if you use the word 'faggot', you have to go to rehab."

Yeah, that's just what CPAC needs -- an association with homophobia. Nice work, Ann.

At some point, Republicans will need to get over their issues with homosexuality. Regardless of whether one believes it to be a choice or a hardwired response, it has little impact on anyone but the gay or lesbian person. We can argue that homosexuality doesn't require legal protection, but not when we have our front-line activists referring to them as "faggots" or worse. That indicates a disturbing level of animosity rather than a true desire to allow people the same rights and protections regardless of their lifestyles.

Ann Coulter can be an entertaining and incisive wit. Unfortunately, she can also be a loose cannon, and CPAC might want to consider that the next time around.

UPDATE: Sean Hackbarth has the audio.

UPDATE II and BUMP: Fascinating discussion in the comments. Since this is likely going to remain a hot topic today, let me add a few more thoughts in response to the points raised.

First, criticizing Coulter's use of the word "faggot" is not a suppression of free speech; it is an exercise of free speech. We're not advocating her arrest for using the word. We're just saying it was stupid, unnecessary, and hateful. This is no different than Melissa McEwan calling Christians "Christofascist Godbags" and Amanda Marcotte's incendiary hate speech about Catholics. We howled about that when John Edwards hired them; why do we defend Coulter's appearance at CPAC?

Also, if CPAC continues to invite Coulter to these events, then unfortunately, these little rhetorical bombs reflect on conservatives. We just spent most of the week criticizing John McCain for not meeting the conservative base at CPAC. If Coulter said this in an interview on her own, it would not have reflected on CPAC or conservatives but on herself. Yesterday, though, she used our platform for that little nugget of vileness -- and some in the audience cheered her for it. Conclusions can reasonably be drawn from that.

I had to laugh when someone noted the use of the word "fag" and "faggot" in Fast Times at Ridgemont High and the song "Money For Nothing". Yes, they're there, but we're not supposed to think highly of the people that use them. In the song, the "voice" is a whiny, shallow man (a physical laborer, for a bit of class warfare from Dire Straits) who thinks that musicians do nothing all day long. It's a critique, not a celebration, of that voice, from a musician obviously tired of hearing those comments from naysayers. In Fast Times, it's used for a realistic view of how teenage boys ridicule anything different. In fact, both of these comparisons show one of the problems with Coulter: she's juvenile. She's arguing at the level of a thirteen-year-old.

A few commenters compared "faggot" to the N-word, saying that gays use it as a term of endearment and then get hypocritically offended when straights use it to describe them. I'm not familiar with that level of usage, but let's say it's true. If Ann Coulter got up and desceribed Barack Obama as a "n----r" as part of a joke at an event like CPAC, would you think that reflected well on conservatives? Uh, no.

Bottom line: Coulter's remark was indefensible. She had the right to say it, but that doesn't make her right for saying it, and she deserves every bit of criticism she's getting.

UPDATE III: The Dire Straits song is actually titled "Money for Nothing", not "I Want My MTV". Thanks to the CQ commenters who pointed this out in the comments; I've corrected it above.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.captainsquartersblog.com/mt/cq082307.cgi/9307

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Coulter Said What? (Bumped):

» CPAC from The Crossed Pond
Today was the day for the Conservative Political Action Conference, the most important event this early in the 2008 race for either party. It essentially functions as a “first look” for the hardcore Republican base at the early candidates ... [Read More]

» Coulter - she went too far from Mark My Words
Ann Coulter can be funny and very sharp. At times however, her rhetoric can get in the way of making a valid point. [Read More]

» Coulter Jumps The Shark … from A Second Hand Conjecture
… for good. Michelle Malkin (via Capt. Ed) with the eyewitness account: ***4:15pm update*** Ann Coulter just finished her riff on Al Gore, tossed out some cute jokes (”You can understand why Hollywood is concerned about global warming. Y... [Read More]

» Nibbles // Open Post -- 2007.03.02 from Bill's Bites
Just read 'em. Maybe I'll find time to do more with 'em later. (And some things that are too short to excerpt and too good to not mention.) Please feel free to use this post for comments and trackbacks not [Read More]

» Bill's Nibbles // Open Post -- 2007.03.02 from Old War Dogs
Some Bill's Bites posts, some things I excerpted and linked but I'm sending you to the original post. I may rearrange the order of the items within this post as I add new things that I think belong above the [Read More]

» Ann Coulter stars in Jackass 3 from The Gantry Launchpad
I used to enjoy at least some of Ann Coulter's work. When she kept out of the gutter she could be inventively witty and genuinely funny. Alas, she has become more and more hatefully unpleasant. The most recent incident (courtesy of Captain Ed) involves... [Read More]

» The Shame Of Ann Coulter from The Moderate Voice
Hasn’t it come time to finally say it? Commentator Ann Coulter has gone way beyond being a provocative speaker and writer and has evolved into someone who is no longer just a verbal bomb thrower but someone who seemingly demeans those who invite ... [Read More]

» Ann Coulter Calls John Edwards ‘Faggot’ from Outside The Beltway | OTB
Ann Coulter just finished her stand-up routine. I missed the first part of it, so I’m not sure what the dumbest thing she said was. She needs to update her material, though, since she’s making Phil Donohue jokes. Hint: No one under 40... [Read More]

» The Captain Has This One Right; Ann Coulter Is Out Of Line from The Opinionator
Via Captain Ed, we learn that Ann Coulter essentially called John Edwards a faggot. While I share many North Carolina resident's disdain for Edwards, this is stupid and inappropriate. She needs to apologize. Several points the good Captain makes that I... [Read More]

» The Captain Has This One Right; Ann Coulter Is Out Of Line from The Opinionator
Via Captain Ed, we learn that Ann Coulter essentially called John Edwards a faggot. While I share many North Carolina resident's disdain for Edwards, this is stupid and inappropriate. She needs to apologize. Several points the good Captain makes that I... [Read More]

» Nutroots double standards strike again: Responses to Coulter versus responses to Stark -and Marcottegate- don’t add up from Sister Toldjah
Jules Crittenden, among other bloggers, writes today about the latest Ann Coulter outrage, this time for calling John Edwards the “F” word (Sean Hackbarth has the audio here). My feelings on Ann Coulter are well known among my readers, so k... [Read More]

» Ann Coulter calls John Edwards a "faggot" from Right Thoughts...not right wing, just right.
On what planet is this kind of bigoted hate speech acceptable? Now, I realize she was referencing the Isiah Washington/T.R. Knight/Grey's Anatomy thing, but here's the problem. Isiah was flat-out wrong to say what he said. It wasn't ... [Read More]

» Coulter's Incessant Mouthing Off from Simianbrain
I decided to do a little digging this morning to see how the conservative blogs were responding to Ann Coulter's latest... I don't even know how to phrase what it was. "Gaffe" makes it sound accidental, "transgression" gives it an air of authority we... [Read More]

» Feigned Outrage from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» Feigned Outrage from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» Feigned Outrage from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» Feigned Outrage from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» Feigned and Real Outrages from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» Feigned and Real Outrages from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» The Captain Has This One Right; Ann Coulter Is Out Of Line from The Opinionator
Via Captain Ed, we learn that Ann Coulter essentially called John Edwards a faggot. While I share many North Carolina resident's disdain for Edwards, this is stupid and inappropriate. She needs to apologize. Several points the good Captain makes that I... [Read More]

» Feigned and Real Outrages from UNCoRRELATED
Last night I was reading Michelle Malkin's blog to see what was going on at CPAC. She recounted Ann Coulter's remarks, including her obtuse reference to John Edwards as a "faggot". I suspect that this is less offensive than indicative... [Read More]

» Horward Dean Expects Me To Denouce Ann Coulter For Saying Faggot (video) from Passionate America
I am outraged at the hateful bigoted remarks by Howard Dean. It is obvious he hates women, Republicans, and free speech. Howard YAAAEEEHHHHH Dean issued a press release filed with queer arguments. ... [Read More]

» Coulter Is Annoying II from Sensible Mom
Plus it makes her look like she's suffering from A BDS-like disease, let's call it LDS (liberal derangement syndrome), when she calls people names instead discussing issues like an adult. [Read More]

» Words From the Heart from baldilocks
At the CPAC Conference in Washington, DC, conservative media star Ann Coulter said this:I’d say something about [2008 Democratic presidential candidate Former Senator] John Edwards, but if you say ‘f*ggot’ you have to go to rehab.And some people ... [Read More]

» Words From the Heart from baldilocks
At the CPAC Conference in Washington, DC, conservative media star Ann Coulter said this:I’d say something about [2008 Democratic presidential candidate Former Senator] John Edwards, but if you say ‘f*ggot’ you have to go to rehab.And some people ... [Read More]

» Conservatives Denounce and Shun Ann Coulter For Edwards Remark from Liberal Values
There’s far more. With quotes like these it isn’t even necessary to look at the liberals who are denouncing here. The conservatives are doing a fine job of it. ... [Read More]

» Too Far Gone from Mind of Mog
“I was going to have a few comments on the other Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards, but it turns out you have to go into rehab if you use the word ‘faggot,’ so I — so kind of an impasse, can’t really talk about Edwards.” Ann C... [Read More]

» Three GOP Frontrunners All Denounce Coulter’s Slur Of John Edwards from Decision '08
Oh, dear, what have we here?  I was assured by Glenn Greenwald that every major political figure on the right was a craven coward who would never take on Ann Coulter, that intellectual powerhouse who epitomizes the modern conservative movement: The pe... [Read More]

» CPAC is Shocked--Shocked!--by Ann Coulter's Remark from Jon Swift
Who knew that Coulter would say something that would give liberals an excuse to attack conservatives? [Read More]

» Ann Coulter at CPAC from Amy Ridenour\'s National Center Blog
I\'m sorry to see that Ann Coulter once again made certain news coverage of CPAC would be focused upon her instead [Read More]

» protein wisdom: the site that LOVES ANN COULTER AND HATES TEH GAYS! from protein wisdom

At least, that's what the implication is in this post at Simianbrain:I decided to do a little digging this morning to see how the conservative blogs were responding to Ann Coulter's latest… I don't even know how to phrase what i...

[Read More]

» Ann Coulter from The Florida Masochist
Ann can say whatever she pleases. I'll defend her right to do her shtick, TFM just reserves the right to call her a Knucklehead when appropriate. [Read More]

» What Would We Do Without Ann Coulter? from jaceonline
If we didn't have our collective butt cheeks in such a clinch, we'd recognize this as a joke. And a finely crafted joke, at that. [Read More]

» Yeah, But You All Do it Too! from A Newer World
Normally, I wouldn’t waste time by writing about Ann Coulter, but the latest controversy is just too rich. No, I’m not surprised that Coulter called presidential candidate John Edwards a “faggot.” That’s mild compared to ... [Read More]